Sheetz Milkshakes Menu

Cheezecake Shake

The Cheezecake Shake is one of the standout drinks on this menu, made with real Philadelphia Cream Cheese for that rich, tangy flavor. It’s thick, dessert-like, and often topped with graham crumbs and whipped cream. If you love cheesecake, this is worth trying first.

Sh’weet Liberty Cheezecake Shake

$5.79 | 985 Cal

Cinnamon Roll Cheezecake Milkshake

$5.49 | 969 Cal

Sh’morez Cheesecake

$5.79 | 959 Cal

Blue Raspberry Cheezecake

$5.59 | 932 Cal

Cherry Cheezecake

$5.59 | 944 Cal

Classic Cheezecake

$5.19 | 911 Cal

Strawberry Fuzion Cheezecake

$5.79 | 964 Cal

Fruit Fuzion Cheezecake

$5.79 | 976 Cal

Premium Cheezecake

$5.79 | 1092 Cal

Decadent Delight Cheezecake

$5.79 | 971 Cal

Caramel Brownie Cheezecake

$5.79 | 1530 Cal

Peanut Butter Brownie Cheezecake

$5.79 | 1687 Cal

Create Your Own Shake

Want full control over your drink? The Create Your Own Shake option lets you pick a base, flavor, mix-ins, and toppings from scratch. It’s a favorite among regulars who like to experiment with new combinations every visit.

Create A Shake Blue Raspberry

$4.69 | 617 Cal

Create A Shake Cherry Vanilla

$4.69 | 745 Cal

Create A Shake Banana

$4.69 | 367 Cal

Create A Shake Black Raspberry

$4.69 | 803 Cal

Create A Shake Cookiez-n-Cream

$5.19 | 367 Cal

Create A Shake Chocolate

$4.69 | 589 Cal

Create A Shake Peanut Butter

$4.69 | 367 Cal

Create A Shake Strawberry

$4.69 | 539 Cal

Create A Shake Vanilla

$4.69 | 510 Cal

Signature Milkshake Recipes

If building your own feels like too many decisions, the Signature Milkshake Recipes give you pre-designed combos like Caramel Brownie Cheezecake or a Reese’s-inspired peanut butter cup shake. These are crafted to hit the right balance of flavors without you having to guess.

Firewerkz Shake

$6.29 | 883 Cal

Cinnamon Roll

$5.49 | 707 Cal

Peach Milkshake

$4.69 | 524 Cal

Peach Berry Milkshake

$4.69 | 860 Cal

Peach Raspberry Milkshake

$4.69 | 888 Cal

Peach Strawberry Milkshake

$4.69 | 808 Cal

Sh’morez

$4.59 | 300 Cal

Reese’s Caramel Cup

$6.49 | 1150 Cal

Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast

$5.49 | 1989 Cal

Peanut Butter Lover

$5.19 | 979 Cal

Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie

$5.49 | 1729 Cal

Best Mix-Ins and Toppings to Try

A great shake often comes down to the mix-ins. Here’s a look at some of the most popular add-ons:

How to Build Your Own Milkshake at Sheetz

Building your shake is simple, whether you’re at the kiosk, in the app, or at the drive-thru. Here’s the process:

• Pick your base — vanilla, chocolate, or a specialty cheesecake base
• Choose a flavor syrup — caramel, hazelnut, or sugar-free options
• Add mix-ins — cookies, candies, or brownie bites
• Top it off — whipped cream, sprinkles, cherries, or chopped nuts
• Boost it — add an espresso shot for a caffeinated twist